Boundary Disputes Vs Party Wall Disputes

Are you about to embark on Party Wall works—or has your neighbour just served notice on you?

If the plans brush up against the boundary line, involve line of junction walls, or raise questions about airspace and fence lines, it’s vital to understand how the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 interacts (and doesn’t interact) with boundary issues.

Below is a clear, practical guide to help you avoid costly missteps and manage expectations from the outset.


1) Party Wall Surveyor Limitation of Duties

Under the Act, party wall surveyors have a statutory job: to resolve the party wall dispute and agree an Award that governs how notifiable works proceed. They do not have jurisdiction to decide where the legal boundary lies.

  • A good surveyor will state this early and plainly if boundary location becomes a live question.
  • The Award focuses on rights and protections for notifiable works—not on title or boundary determination.

Key takeaway: If your question is “Where is the boundary, exactly?”—that is outside the party wall surveyor’s remit.


2) Line of Junction Works: What the Award Does and Does Not Do

Where a building owner serves a Section 1 notice (line of junction works) to build up to (s.1(5)) or astride (s.1(2)) the boundary:

  • An Award may give the right to build up to or astride the line of junction subject to the Act, but it does not certify or confirm where that line actually is.
  • The Award will often reference design drawings to describe the proposed position; that is descriptive, not determinative of the legal boundary.

Key takeaway: An Award can authorise how you build relative to a line of junction, but it does not prove where the legal boundary sits.


3) Differing Opinions on Boundary Location: What Happens?

If owners disagree about the true boundary location:

  • The drawings included in the Award and the Award itself do not settle that disagreement.
  • The party wall process can still conclude, but if one party later claims the wall encroaches, that becomes a separate boundary/title dispute—outside the party wall surveyor’s powers.
  • Proceeding with works without clarity can expose you to trespass allegations and potential injunctive relief or damages in a different forum.

Practical risk management:

  • Where boundary doubt is material to the works (e.g., astride construction, foundation positions, projecting elements), pause and clarify before you build.

4) Still in Doubt? Instruct a Boundary Surveyor

If uncertainty persists—or the owners are already at odds—bring in a specialist boundary surveyor (or other suitably qualified expert) before the shovel hits the ground:

  • They will examine deeds, historic mapping, measured surveys, physical features, and legal presumptions to produce an expert opinion on the likely boundary location.
  • If needed, parties can seek a joint instruction to appoint one expert, or each party can instruct their own.
  • Where agreement cannot be reached, boundary disputes are ultimately resolved by the courts—not under the Party Wall Act.

Key takeaway: Use the right expert for the right question. Party wall surveyors manage party wall rights and protections; boundary surveyors determine where the line lies.


Practical Tips to Keep Your Project on Track

  • Be candid early. If you suspect a boundary dispute, raise it before finalising construction drawings and notices.
  • Draft notices intelligently. For s.1 works, consider acknowledging the possibility of reverting from s.1(2) (astride) to s.1(5) (wholly on your land) if consent isn’t forthcoming.
  • Don’t conflate processes. The party wall Award won’t cure a boundary dispute; treat them as parallel but distinct issues.
  • Protect relationships. Neighbour goodwill is invaluable. Clear explanations and realistic timelines reduce friction, referrals, and legal spend.

Get Clarity Before You Build

Simple Survey (RICS)Plain-English party wall guidance, nationwide, fixed fees.
Email team@simplesurvey.co.uk with your drawings and a brief outline of your scheme. We’ll confirm what’s notifiable, flag boundary risk points, and set out the cleanest route to a valid, defensible Award.
Simple Survey are experienced and RICS qualified.


Simple Survey — Fixed Nationwide Costs (Guide)

ServiceWhat’s IncludedFixed Fee (incl. VAT)
Party Wall Notice (per Adjoining Owner)Drafting, validity checks, compliant service & tracking£25
Agreed Surveyor AwardOne impartial surveyor acting for both owners£300
Building Owner’s Surveyor AwardActing for BO in a two-surveyor appointment£300

Our fees are always fixed. We’re nationwide. We’re experienced and RICS-qualified.


FAQ

Q1: Can the party wall Award tell us where the legal boundary is?
A: No. An Award can authorise how works proceed relative to a line of junction, but it does not determine the legal boundary.

Q2: We disagree on the boundary; can the party wall surveyors decide?
A: No. Boundary determination is outside their jurisdiction. You’ll need a boundary surveyor (and possibly legal routes) to resolve it.

Q3: If the neighbour refuses an astride wall (s.1(2)), what then?
A: You must revert to s.1(5) and build wholly on your land, subject to notice and the Act’s protections/rights (including access, where applicable).

Q4: Can we still conclude a Party Wall Award while a boundary dispute rumbles on?
A: Often yes, but you proceed at risk if the works depend on the precise boundary. Consider pausing for boundary clarification where positioning is critical.

Q5: Who pays for the boundary expert?
A: Boundary disputes sit outside the Party Wall Act’s cost regime. Responsibility depends on agreement between owners or court direction in litigation.


Have drawings ready—or a notice already on your mat?
Email: team@simplesurvey.co.uk for fast, friendly, RICS-qualified help that keeps projects moving and neighbours on side.